Free speech and free thinking are core values of the National Conversation. We host – and aim to inspire – forums where people feel free to speak freely. So to speak.
Some thoughts from Tom Chivers at The Telegraph blogs on the rights and wrongs of comment moderation.
Last night saw the York Conversation, with around 20 people starting a conversation around the topic: “is the welfare state still fit for purpose?” More on this later, when we will be posting video content.
Thanks again to City of York Council for making the York Conversation possible.
As we approach the seventieth anniversary of the publication of the Beveridge Report, we’ve been asking commentators for their thoughts about Beveridge and his legacy.
Today’s 3 Questions on Beveridge come from Quentin Letts of the Daily Mail. Thanks to Quentin for his thoughtful contribution. We are always happy to receive your ideas. We want to have as broad and informed a conversation as possible.
1) What does the Beveridge Report mean to you?
I associate it with the creation of the original welfare state – something that was based on biting need and, to use the man’s word, squalor. Beveridge is an historical figure and someone I think of with high regard, despite the fact that I consider the modern welfare system to be a disaster. His good intentions have been warped by later welfarians who have devalued the concept by “crying wolf” and over-rewarding the indolent.
2) Are all of Beveridge’s Five Great Evils still relevant today? Do we face any new ones?
Physical squalor is less evident today. Instead we have a moral or attitudinal squalor. A modern Beveridge might worry about how unkind we are, how angry – the levels of public rage are frightening. Also Beveridge today might worry about stress (related to anger), about family connections (divorce is almost as much of a social ill as non-divorce was), gluttony, anti-spiritualism. These are shortcomings of the soul rather than the more physical pangs Beveridge addressed. I wonder if he might also have worried about over-population.
3) Have we slain the Five Great Evils, or any one of them?
Ignorance has in some ways increased. Squalor, as I have just said in answer 2, is now not so much physical as in attitudes. Disease is, thank goodness, far less bad – though it will never be eradicated. Idleness is, I suspect, far, far worse today. You can blame the telly. You can blame the bloated welfare state. The evil which has abated most is want. Are people in modern Britain really still acutely in want? I guess some are but the scale is nothing to what it was.
At BBC Radio York on the Jonathan Cowap show to tell people about tonight’s York Conversation at Gray’s Court and kick start the conversation about the future of the welfare state.
Last night fifteen people came together in York to find out if the Lego Serious Play system could help them talk constructively about politics. More later…
The National Conversation comes to Telegraph blogs. Ruth Dudley Edwards challenges readers to “offend someone today”!
Places are still available for the York Conversation with Claire Fox tomorrow night. (6.00-7.30pm, Gray’s Court Hotel. To make sure you get your voice heard, just drop us a line.
We are reaching out on every channel, to get more people talking about the National Conversation. Today, we’re on the front page of The Huffington Post as a featured article.
Later today: more on last night’s first National Conversation Moot.
Tonight – Tuesday 16 October – Mick Fealty hosts the first National Conversation Moot at 7.00pm.
A Moot is a kind of Web-enabled video conference, allowing people to meet for a face-to-face conversation. Tonight Mick will be trying to get under the skin of the question: is the welfare state still fit for purpose?
Contributors for tonight’s Moot include John Lloyd (contributing editor, Financial Times and co-founder of the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism at Oxford) Dr John Bew (currently working on a biography of Clement Attlee) and Margot James MP.
The Moot is hosted on Google Hangouts. It’s easy to take part if you have a Gmail or Google Plus account. Sign up now – or find out more on the event page.
You can also comment on the Moot after the event on the National Conversation YouTube page.